Cake Is His ‘Art.’ So Can He Deny One to a Gay Couple?

The government, Mr. Phillips contends, should not be allowed to compel him to endorse a message at odds with his beliefs.

“I’m being forced to use my creativity, my talents and my art for an event — a significant religious event — that violates my religious faith,” Mr. Phillips said.

Gay rights groups regard the case as a potent threat to the equality promised by the Supreme Court in 2015 when it said the Constitution guaranteed the right to same-sex marriage. A ruling in favor of Mr. Phillips, they said, would mark the marriages of gay couples as second-class unions unworthy of legal protection.


Charlie Craig, left, and David Mullins at their home in Denver. “It’s not about the cake,” Mr. Craig said. “It is about discrimination.

Read Story